TY - JOUR
T1 - Computed tomography and biomechanical evaluation of screw fixation options at the cervicothoracic junction
T2 - Intralamina versus intrapedicular techniques
AU - Cardoso, Mario J.
AU - Dmitriev, Anton E.
AU - Lehman, Ronald A.
AU - Helgeson, Melvin
AU - Cooper, Patrick
AU - Rosner, Michael K.
PY - 2008/11/15
Y1 - 2008/11/15
N2 - STUDY DESIGN.: In vitro cadaveric biomechanical analysis. OBJECTIVE.: Define the T1 and T2 anatomic lamina size and evaluate the bone-screw interface strength of various pedicle screw options and intralamina techniques. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA.: Transpedicular instrumentation is well accepted, but salvage techniques in the proximal thoracic spine are limited. Intralamina fixation has been described at C2 with favorable biomechanical characteristics. In addition, this technique has been introduced clinically in the proximal thoracic spine. However, the biomechanical potential has not been evaluated. METHODS.: Fourteen fresh-frozen cervicothoracic cadaveric specimens were scanned using dual-energy radiograph absorptiometry for bone mineral density, imaged under computed tomography, and then instrumented in the following configuration: (1) Right-sided pedicle screws in a straight-forward trajectory, (2) "salvage anatomic trajectory pedicle screws, and (3) "salvage" intralamina screws into the contralateral lamina. Insertional torque (IT) was recorded with each revolution and screws were pulled out in-line (POS) with the screw axis to simulate intraoperative failure of fixation. RESULTS.: Lamina screws as a salvage technique generated statistically greater peak IT (P = 0.002) and relative POS (P < 0.05) in comparison with straight-forward transpedicular screws as the initial fixation type. Furthermore, lamina screws, when compared to the salvage anatomic trajectory pedicle screws, had a significantly greater peak IT (P = 0.011). The peak IT showed a stronger correlation with POS in lamina screws than straight-forward or anatomic pedicle screws with a similar trend noted in mean IT. Bone mineral density correlated with POS in all methods of fixation. The mean lamina width measured on computed tomography at the thinnest point was 5.9 ± 0.7 mm (range, 4.9-7.9). CONCLUSION.: Our results suggest that lamina screws, used as a salvage technique in the proximal thoracic spine, provide stronger fixation than transpedicular screws when using standard 4.5-mm cervical screws. In-tralamina screws appear to be a biomechanically sound salvage technique in the region, and appear to be a safe, effective technique for instrumenting the proximal thoracic spine.
AB - STUDY DESIGN.: In vitro cadaveric biomechanical analysis. OBJECTIVE.: Define the T1 and T2 anatomic lamina size and evaluate the bone-screw interface strength of various pedicle screw options and intralamina techniques. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA.: Transpedicular instrumentation is well accepted, but salvage techniques in the proximal thoracic spine are limited. Intralamina fixation has been described at C2 with favorable biomechanical characteristics. In addition, this technique has been introduced clinically in the proximal thoracic spine. However, the biomechanical potential has not been evaluated. METHODS.: Fourteen fresh-frozen cervicothoracic cadaveric specimens were scanned using dual-energy radiograph absorptiometry for bone mineral density, imaged under computed tomography, and then instrumented in the following configuration: (1) Right-sided pedicle screws in a straight-forward trajectory, (2) "salvage anatomic trajectory pedicle screws, and (3) "salvage" intralamina screws into the contralateral lamina. Insertional torque (IT) was recorded with each revolution and screws were pulled out in-line (POS) with the screw axis to simulate intraoperative failure of fixation. RESULTS.: Lamina screws as a salvage technique generated statistically greater peak IT (P = 0.002) and relative POS (P < 0.05) in comparison with straight-forward transpedicular screws as the initial fixation type. Furthermore, lamina screws, when compared to the salvage anatomic trajectory pedicle screws, had a significantly greater peak IT (P = 0.011). The peak IT showed a stronger correlation with POS in lamina screws than straight-forward or anatomic pedicle screws with a similar trend noted in mean IT. Bone mineral density correlated with POS in all methods of fixation. The mean lamina width measured on computed tomography at the thinnest point was 5.9 ± 0.7 mm (range, 4.9-7.9). CONCLUSION.: Our results suggest that lamina screws, used as a salvage technique in the proximal thoracic spine, provide stronger fixation than transpedicular screws when using standard 4.5-mm cervical screws. In-tralamina screws appear to be a biomechanically sound salvage technique in the region, and appear to be a safe, effective technique for instrumenting the proximal thoracic spine.
KW - Cervicothoracic junction
KW - Lamina screw
KW - Pedicle screw
KW - Salvage technique
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=58949096359&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1097/BRS.0b013e31818ce3ac
DO - 10.1097/BRS.0b013e31818ce3ac
M3 - Article
C2 - 19011542
AN - SCOPUS:58949096359
SN - 0362-2436
VL - 33
SP - 2612
EP - 2617
JO - Spine
JF - Spine
IS - 24
ER -