Factors affecting behavioral health provider turnover in US Air Force primary care behavioral health services

Turnover and retention of integrated behavioral health practitioners in primary care is a significant challenge with limited empirical evidence to inform risk factors. This study used retrospective archival data from the Air Force Medical Service’s Behavioral Health Optimization Program on all civilian contractors hired from September 2012 to November 2014 to examine the potential influence of training background (e.g., social work v. psychology), size of healthcare facility, or the presence of on-site mentors. Turnover was evaluated across a large managed healthcare organization of 121 civilian contractors (psychologists and social workers) in 72 specific clinic settings. These sites varied considerably in regards to geographic location, population diversity, size of patient empanelment, rural, suburban, and urban settings and all provided care to active duty military, their civilian dependents and civilian retirees. Results found that 54% of all psychologists and social workers hired for these positions quit or were fired within 8 months of employment. Smaller medical facilities were found to have a more significant attrition rate compared to medium- and large-sized facilities; no other differences were noted. Findings provide initial insight into a potential critical period in the first year of a behavioral health consultants on-boarding, as well as unique considerations for consultants placed in smaller facilities who may be at elevated risk for attrition. These preliminary findings suggest targeted interventions for new integrated care programs as well as important avenues for future research.