Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Phenotypes of Management Reasoning Struggle in Postgraduate Medical Education

  • Andrew S. Parsons*
  • , Matthew Kelleher
  • , James Bowen
  • , Karen M. Warburton
  • , Michael S. Ryan
  • , Walther N.K.A. Van Mook
  • , Steven J. Durning
  • *Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › peer-review

Abstract

Purpose: Clinical reasoning struggles are a leading cause of remediation referrals in postgraduate medical education. Most remediation efforts, like much of the clinical reasoning literature, focus on diagnostic reasoning. Errors in management reasoning can have serious consequences for patients, yet no framework exists for recognizing how learners struggle in this domain or for guiding remediation when they do. Methods: We conducted a multi-institutional qualitative interview study within a constructivist paradigm using the critical incident technique to explore how postgraduate medical trainees struggle with management reasoning in clinical practice, how those struggles are recognized, and how programs respond. Participants were residency program directors and clinical competency committee chairs from U.S. internal medicine and pediatrics programs. Data were analyzed using a systematic cross-case approach to identify phenotypes of management reasoning struggle. Results: We interviewed 20 program directors and clinical competency committee chairs from 15 programs about 15 trainees remediated for management reasoning difficulties. Cross-case analysis identified four phenotypes: (1) limited management scripts (inability to generate or contextualize a plan despite reaching a diagnosis), (2) can’t change course (inability to integrate new clinical information into an existing management plan), (3) impaired task triage and execution (difficulty prioritizing and coordinating management within a complex clinical environment), and (4) failure to calibrate (misjudgment of how much intervention a situation warrants). Contextual (i.e., situational) factors including clinical complexity, patient acuity, diagnostic uncertainty, and reduced supervision increased the likelihood of these phenotypes, and team structures often compensated for struggles before they were recognized. Struggles were frequently misattributed to problems with time management, organization, or communication, and remediation strategies were largely nonspecific across phenotypes. Conclusion: These four phenotypes offer program leaders and frontline educators an empirically grounded vocabulary for recognizing patterns of management reasoning struggle earlier and designing more targeted support.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)718-731
Number of pages14
JournalPerspectives on Medical Education
Volume15
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - 2026

Keywords

  • Clinical Competence/standards
  • Clinical Reasoning
  • Education, Medical, Graduate/methods
  • Humans
  • Interviews as Topic/methods
  • Phenotype
  • Qualitative Research
  • United States

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Phenotypes of Management Reasoning Struggle in Postgraduate Medical Education'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this