Reproducibility of treadmill exercise data in patients with atrial fibrillation

Serial submaximal treadmill tests are often used to evaluate the efficacy of therapy in patients with atrial fibrillation. Since the response to serial tests can be influenced by a ‘learning phenomenon’, we performed maximal exercise tests on 9 patients (mean age 63 ±4 years) with chronic atrial fibrillation. Points of analysis for the initial and follow-up treadmill exercise tests were 3 mph/0% grade, the gas exchange anaerobic threshold, and maximal exertion. Significant (p < 0.05) reductions in ventilation (1/min) and oxygen uptake (ml/kg/min) were observed on follow-up at a standard submaximal work load of 3.0 mph/0% grade and at the gas exchange anaerobic threshold. There was no significant alteration in these variables at maximal exertion. A reduction in heart rate was observed throughout exercise during the follow-up test with the most marked reduction (21 beats/min) occurring at 3.0 mph/0% grade. There were no differences in respiratory exchange ratio or systolic blood pressure at any point. The reduction in submaximal heart rate and gas exchange variables without a significant change in these variables at maximal exertion is consistent with a learning effect. Therefore, studies comparing consecutive submaximal exercise test responses in patients with atrial fibrillation can be misleading.